Twilight News: Hardwicke Out, Weitz In?


So the news came in last weekend that Twilight director Catherine Hardwicke will NOT be directing the next two movies of the franchise, New Moon and Eclipse.  I wasn’t entirely surprised by this move, though I am shocked by what insiders of Summit said of Hardwicke.  According to Deadline Hollywood Daily, Hardwicke “was difficult and irrational during the making of Twilight.”  It goes on saying how Summit plain out didn’t like her.

I guess I’ll never really know if these accusations are true or not, but I find it hard to believe.  The Summit Entertainment press release said how Hardwicke won’t be directing the sequels because of how Summit wants to speed the process up to film the next two sequels back-to-back, starting in about 3 or 4 months.  That doesn’t give Hardwicke enough “prep time to bring her vision of the film to the big screen.”

Okay.  I’m fine with that.  I’m also okay with how she probably wanted more money, and now with the blown-out success of Twilight there should be a huge increase in budget for the sequels… and Hardwicke is more the indie-filmmaker, who knows what she’ll do with $100 million.  But you can’t take away what she did for Twilight.  She took a huge movie with high expectations and made it a legitimate teen, sci-fi film for only $37 million.  It has grossed over $138 million in three weeks, and though it probably would’ve made that much if a monkey directed it, Hardwicke actually made the movie pretty good.

So what’s next for the Twilight Saga?  There have been reports that The Golden Compass director/writer Chris Weitz has been offered to direct New Moon.  Well, all the power to female directors has just gone out the window.  Weitz would be a solid choice, although The Golden Compass was a flop.  It’s assured that New Moon won’t be a dud, unless there is some serious backlash for axing Hardwicke… but that’ll probably disappear in a few weeks.

But really?  Chris Weitz?  His adaptation of The Golden Compass didn’t do the Philip Pullman classics justice.  The Catholics of the world were heavily against the release of the movie.  Weitz certainly was feeling a lot of heat from them, and while writing and shooting the film made some very controversial adjustments to the story.  I read the book, and let’s just say what he did is comparable to if Twilight had ended right when it was known that James was tracking Bella.  Weitz left out the final few chapters of the novel and therefore ended the film before the most significant sequence took place.  I don’t know what he was thinking.

I’m sure he’s learned his lesson… right?  So now we just have to wait to see if he accepts Summit’s offer or not.  My opinion… he’s already crumbled under pressure once with a big-time fantasy film.  He should stick with small comedies that get critical acclaim, like About a Boy.  He’s not the director the Twilight Saga needs.


2 Responses to Twilight News: Hardwicke Out, Weitz In?

  1. christapie says:

    No! Not Weitz! If Weitz directs Edward might never leave town! MTV posted a list of potentials. Off that list I would choose David Fincher. As I posted in my blog I liked the words they used to describe him: obsessive meticulousness. I even liked the Cons that they posted, saying he’d give girls nightmares. Of course, I don’t believe anyone would actually kill off Edward, but I could imagine seeing the various options he’s contemplating through Alice’s eyes.

  2. herculesrob says:

    I have read the article about possible directors for New Moon, and have to say that I feel that Mira Nair or Brad Silberling would be the best fit out of the choices MTV laid out. Mira would be great at containing the romance aspect from a female’s perspective, but it was noted that she’s too busy. Silberling is talented, but hasn’t made the big-production films that New Moon seems to be asking for. Could he handle that?

    They are far from the best directors from the list. You said how you want David Fincher… he’s a phenomenal director, arguably one of the best of our generation. I highly doubt he’ll pick up a teen-romance vampire franchise after working on masterpieces like Fight Club, Se7en, Zodiac, and the current The Curious Case of Benjamin Button. Plus his asking price will be too large, especially after directing the $150 million budget of Benjamin Button. He’s out of Summit’s range. So is Roman Polanski, Robert Rodriguez, and Ang Lee.

    I was under the impression that Twilight was all about girl-power, with a female author, screenwriter, and director. It seems that this is changing and might affect the franchise. There has already been a backlash of plenty of fans expressing their anger from the dismissal of Hardwicke. We just have to wait and see what happens.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: